Shifting SUCKS in my car....
#26
hey, have you ever figured this out? my 08 (or 09.. not sure) is the exact same way. its not overly hard to shift at low rpm but while driving and doing WOT runs its impossible. i have a couple k20 buddies who get in it and go wot and try to quick change like a typical honda and they pop the cables out of the clamp.. the cables are brand new and i replaced the roll pin in the linkage. i lost the engine 2 months ago and am doing a full build including all front end parts. i have the entire front end ordered, the billet engine mounts, and transmission mounts. i also am doing a new clutch with oem flywheel, ottp shifter, and anything that could possibly be hindering my shifting. id like to know where you got with this because what you describe is identical to my issue.
^^will fix the cables popping off
Did you replace this part when you did the cables? Or make sure it's holding the cables correctly?
LSJ Revised Shifter Bracket - Transmission & Drivetrain
#27
Chevrolet Cobalt SS/NA Cable Clamp
^^will fix the cables popping off
Did you replace this part when you did the cables? Or make sure it's holding the cables correctly?
LSJ Revised Shifter Bracket - Transmission & Drivetrain
^^will fix the cables popping off
Did you replace this part when you did the cables? Or make sure it's holding the cables correctly?
LSJ Revised Shifter Bracket - Transmission & Drivetrain
#28
I didn't replace it but I made sure it was holding right. I am cleaning up and painting the engine Bay and with that I was going to do Powell engine mounts, zzp trans mounts, clutch, oem flywheel, billet shifter cable clamp, master/slave cylinder, and the zzp adjustable rod thingy. this is a little project car I have going on and I want it to never ever shift again like it used to. that lsj bracket is what I want for my lnf?
Make sure you replace the clutch pipe, and use new flywheel bolts. I dont know of any reason to use the adjustable rod with a stock clutch.
#29
Thread Starter
Junior Member
iTrader: (2)
Joined: 10-11-15
Posts: 414
Likes: 12
From: Seattle, WA area
hey, have you ever figured this out? my 08 (or 09.. not sure) is the exact same way. its not overly hard to shift at low rpm but while driving and doing WOT runs its impossible. i have a couple k20 buddies who get in it and go wot and try to quick change like a typical honda and they pop the cables out of the clamp.. the cables are brand new and i replaced the roll pin in the linkage. i lost the engine 2 months ago and am doing a full build including all front end parts. i have the entire front end ordered, the billet engine mounts, and transmission mounts. i also am doing a new clutch with oem flywheel, ottp shifter, and anything that could possibly be hindering my shifting. id like to know where you got with this because what you describe is identical to my issue.
I am going to be throwing a used transaxle in soon. I am 100% convinced it's the trans.
There are many MANY complaints on the Saab 9-3 and 9-5 boards about this exact problem.
Saab even released an update kit to fix these exact issues.
Tonight I will link a few good reads about this exact issue in the Saab 9-3s. Same exact problem.
#30
I was going to upgrade the clutch and go with oem flywheel. unless I should upgrade the clutch and use a fidenza flywheel. hence why I was going to get the rod. I was talking to John at Powell race parts this evening and he is convinced I just need an lnf clutch
#31
I am going to be throwing a used transaxle in soon. I am 100% convinced it's the trans.
There are many MANY complaints on the Saab 9-3 and 9-5 boards about this exact problem.
Saab even released an update kit to fix these exact issues.
Tonight I will link a few good reads about this exact issue in the Saab 9-3s. Same exact problem.
There are many MANY complaints on the Saab 9-3 and 9-5 boards about this exact problem.
Saab even released an update kit to fix these exact issues.
Tonight I will link a few good reads about this exact issue in the Saab 9-3s. Same exact problem.
#32
Keep with the OEM flywheel.
#33
Thread Starter
Junior Member
iTrader: (2)
Joined: 10-11-15
Posts: 414
Likes: 12
From: Seattle, WA area
I'm up in the air about my clutch. It sure feels aftermarket. Engagement isn't too far off the floor and it's on the stiff side. It's been holding everything I throw at it.
I might just keep it in there because it seems to be just fine.
It's tempting to go with GMPP though for a softer pedal but I'm not sure I want to sink even more money into the car yet.
I figure after doing the trans in this once the second time won't be nearly as bad so a future clutch won't be a huge deal.
**I did install the ZZP adjustable master cylinder. It didn't make any difference really.
I just don't see how the adjustment can really help. With my stock master the rod would bottom out on the housing. With the ZZP, the rod bottoms out on the housing. Other than moving the pedal position a bit I don't see how it can possible dis engage the pressure plate any more than the stock one.
I might be over looking something though.
When I say the rod bottoms out I'm talking about that beveled shape thing on the rod. It hits the master cylinder on both the stock and aftermarket rod.
I did adjust the ZZP one so that when the pedal is on the floor the rod is just touching the master. Anything more and you'll be bending the firewall / bashing the housing.
Sadly I'll be swapping it again. The one I got has a nice leak internally into the car.
I purchased another one from ZZP so I can send the 1st one back for their "inspection".
On the topic of master cylinders. I have worked with thousands of cars over the years. When I bleed brakes / clutches I apply pressure to the reservoir then go crack the bleeders open. Works great. I tend to apply only 1-2 psi at the reservoir with a hand pump when doing this. I have never had a master leak internally doing this. I told ZZP how I bled the system. I hope this doesn't turn into being blamed for making it leak.
I might just keep it in there because it seems to be just fine.
It's tempting to go with GMPP though for a softer pedal but I'm not sure I want to sink even more money into the car yet.
I figure after doing the trans in this once the second time won't be nearly as bad so a future clutch won't be a huge deal.
**I did install the ZZP adjustable master cylinder. It didn't make any difference really.
I just don't see how the adjustment can really help. With my stock master the rod would bottom out on the housing. With the ZZP, the rod bottoms out on the housing. Other than moving the pedal position a bit I don't see how it can possible dis engage the pressure plate any more than the stock one.
I might be over looking something though.
When I say the rod bottoms out I'm talking about that beveled shape thing on the rod. It hits the master cylinder on both the stock and aftermarket rod.
I did adjust the ZZP one so that when the pedal is on the floor the rod is just touching the master. Anything more and you'll be bending the firewall / bashing the housing.
Sadly I'll be swapping it again. The one I got has a nice leak internally into the car.
I purchased another one from ZZP so I can send the 1st one back for their "inspection".
On the topic of master cylinders. I have worked with thousands of cars over the years. When I bleed brakes / clutches I apply pressure to the reservoir then go crack the bleeders open. Works great. I tend to apply only 1-2 psi at the reservoir with a hand pump when doing this. I have never had a master leak internally doing this. I told ZZP how I bled the system. I hope this doesn't turn into being blamed for making it leak.
#34
Thread Starter
Junior Member
iTrader: (2)
Joined: 10-11-15
Posts: 414
Likes: 12
From: Seattle, WA area
hey, have you ever figured this out? my 08 (or 09.. not sure) is the exact same way. its not overly hard to shift at low rpm but while driving and doing WOT runs its impossible. i have a couple k20 buddies who get in it and go wot and try to quick change like a typical honda and they pop the cables out of the clamp.. the cables are brand new and i replaced the roll pin in the linkage. i lost the engine 2 months ago and am doing a full build including all front end parts. i have the entire front end ordered, the billet engine mounts, and transmission mounts. i also am doing a new clutch with oem flywheel, ottp shifter, and anything that could possibly be hindering my shifting. id like to know where you got with this because what you describe is identical to my issue.
Does your trans occasionally decide to just come out of 5th gear when cruising?
It tends to happen when going from cruise to coast then back to cruise.
No noise, nothing. Just suddenly it's not in gear. Take it out of 5th and put it back in and it's good again for miles and miles. If I don't pull it back to neutral first it will cause the dogs to grind when trying to push it back into 5th.
Again, it's NOT the cable / shifter adjustment. I have torn every aspect of the system apart, inspected, measured and made damned sure the lever / cables are moving the shift levers on the transaxle properly and completely.
I see a bright side to all my trans woes.
1. I'm getting a 32k mile HHR trans with LSD. Shorter FD = a little easier on trans.
2. I'll have all kinds of spare parts. Think case, gears etc.
3. Hopefully I'll be able to recoup most of my expense by parting out my old trans.
4. I need to be positive because this crap is pissing me off lol. I really REALLY want to do a wot run and see just how quick this thing is. By the time i'm able to grab the next gear boost is long gone which takes 80% of the fun out of it.
If this doesn't solve it then the only thing left is my clutch. I know it fully disengages when I press it down but if this doesn't change my shifting issues I will get a GMPP and drop the trans again.
But with the 5th gear thing, high rpm shift thing, reverse locked out etc it's GOT to be something screwed up in the trans. Especially after reading all the saab guys having the same issue and seeing Saab's update repair kit.
Last edited by firehawk618; 11-10-2015 at 06:36 PM.
#35
Thread Starter
Junior Member
iTrader: (2)
Joined: 10-11-15
Posts: 414
Likes: 12
From: Seattle, WA area
Read:
https://www.genuinesaab.com/psi/gearbox.htm
And
http://www.saabcentral.com/forums/sh...d.php?t=223931
And the most relevant one I believe:
https://www.genuinesaab.com/psi/file...ans-update.htm
I realize the sn breakdown shows these to be an issue with the early trans but who knows what parts big GM reached into when sourcing our Coblat / HHR trans......
https://www.genuinesaab.com/psi/gearbox.htm
And
http://www.saabcentral.com/forums/sh...d.php?t=223931
And the most relevant one I believe:
https://www.genuinesaab.com/psi/file...ans-update.htm
I realize the sn breakdown shows these to be an issue with the early trans but who knows what parts big GM reached into when sourcing our Coblat / HHR trans......
Last edited by firehawk618; 11-10-2015 at 06:43 PM.
The following users liked this post:
firehawk618 (11-10-2015)
#37
Thread Starter
Junior Member
iTrader: (2)
Joined: 10-11-15
Posts: 414
Likes: 12
From: Seattle, WA area
Are you speaking from personal experience on dismantling one of these? I would love to hear about some gotcha's that people have experienced in the past on these.
I realize they list a huge list of "special" tools but in my experience rarely are they truly needed and a crafty person can typically rig up their own jigs to get the job done.
#40
Does your trans occasionally decide to just come out of 5th gear when cruising?
It tends to happen when going from cruise to coast then back to cruise.
No noise, nothing. Just suddenly it's not in gear. Take it out of 5th and put it back in and it's good again for miles and miles. If I don't pull it back to neutral first it will cause the dogs to grind when trying to push it back into 5th.
Again, it's NOT the cable / shifter adjustment. I have torn every aspect of the system apart, inspected, measured and made damned sure the lever / cables are moving the shift levers on the transaxle properly and completely.
I see a bright side to all my trans woes.
1. I'm getting a 32k mile HHR trans with LSD. Shorter FD = a little easier on trans.
2. I'll have all kinds of spare parts. Think case, gears etc.
3. Hopefully I'll be able to recoup most of my expense by parting out my old trans.
4. I need to be positive because this crap is pissing me off lol. I really REALLY want to do a wot run and see just how quick this thing is. By the time i'm able to grab the next gear boost is long gone which takes 80% of the fun out of it.
If this doesn't solve it then the only thing left is my clutch. I know it fully disengages when I press it down but if this doesn't change my shifting issues I will get a GMPP and drop the trans again.
But with the 5th gear thing, high rpm shift thing, reverse locked out etc it's GOT to be something screwed up in the trans. Especially after reading all the saab guys having the same issue and seeing Saab's update repair kit.
It tends to happen when going from cruise to coast then back to cruise.
No noise, nothing. Just suddenly it's not in gear. Take it out of 5th and put it back in and it's good again for miles and miles. If I don't pull it back to neutral first it will cause the dogs to grind when trying to push it back into 5th.
Again, it's NOT the cable / shifter adjustment. I have torn every aspect of the system apart, inspected, measured and made damned sure the lever / cables are moving the shift levers on the transaxle properly and completely.
I see a bright side to all my trans woes.
1. I'm getting a 32k mile HHR trans with LSD. Shorter FD = a little easier on trans.
2. I'll have all kinds of spare parts. Think case, gears etc.
3. Hopefully I'll be able to recoup most of my expense by parting out my old trans.
4. I need to be positive because this crap is pissing me off lol. I really REALLY want to do a wot run and see just how quick this thing is. By the time i'm able to grab the next gear boost is long gone which takes 80% of the fun out of it.
If this doesn't solve it then the only thing left is my clutch. I know it fully disengages when I press it down but if this doesn't change my shifting issues I will get a GMPP and drop the trans again.
But with the 5th gear thing, high rpm shift thing, reverse locked out etc it's GOT to be something screwed up in the trans. Especially after reading all the saab guys having the same issue and seeing Saab's update repair kit.
#41
Thread Starter
Junior Member
iTrader: (2)
Joined: 10-11-15
Posts: 414
Likes: 12
From: Seattle, WA area
Might just be your clutch then.
Mine now shifts exactly as it should.
I cannot say whether or not my old clutch played a factor in it because I replaced it at the same time as my trans.
My trans was most definitely f'd up and on borrowed time.
Mine now shifts exactly as it should.
I cannot say whether or not my old clutch played a factor in it because I replaced it at the same time as my trans.
My trans was most definitely f'd up and on borrowed time.
#42
probably TWM. I have it. You either have slight difficulty going into 1st and reverse, or you have difficulty going into reverse.
I chose having the cables adjusted to the point that its difficult to go into reverse because I use 1st too often lol. Usually going into 4th or 2nd help find reverse.
I chose having the cables adjusted to the point that its difficult to go into reverse because I use 1st too often lol. Usually going into 4th or 2nd help find reverse.
#43
Thread Starter
Junior Member
iTrader: (2)
Joined: 10-11-15
Posts: 414
Likes: 12
From: Seattle, WA area
probably TWM. I have it. You either have slight difficulty going into 1st and reverse, or you have difficulty going into reverse.
I chose having the cables adjusted to the point that its difficult to go into reverse because I use 1st too often lol. Usually going into 4th or 2nd help find reverse.
I chose having the cables adjusted to the point that its difficult to go into reverse because I use 1st too often lol. Usually going into 4th or 2nd help find reverse.
After getting my trans issues ironed out I put my TWM back in and it works fine. No issue at all going into any gear.
I push it all the way to the stop then up into 5th.
I lift the interlock and go far right then down to reverse.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
The Rookie24
Drivetrain
3
09-20-2015 04:33 PM