View Poll Results: For a 20% savings would you buy a lower quality china part over a USA part
Multiple Choice Poll. Voters: 65. You may not vote on this poll
China vs USA made products
#1
China vs USA made products
I am curious how cobalt owners feel in general about where the parts for their cars are made. Post up your thoughts and stories please. Vote in the poll also.
Last question....We all know things can be made a lot more cheaply over there and it does affect the quality but do you think you would be able to spot the difference between a product made here and a product made there?
Last question....We all know things can be made a lot more cheaply over there and it does affect the quality but do you think you would be able to spot the difference between a product made here and a product made there?
#2
Senior Member
iTrader: (3)
Honestly some of the China and Asian steel is becoming better quality than USA. However, precision and limited quantity runs keep the quality in check here, whereas they just crank it out. My ark exhaust has seen every winter since it's installation and still looks nicer than the magnaflow after one year.
#4
Got Bewst?
iTrader: (8)
It really depends what it is. ZZP's dual pass is made in China. It served me well for 2 years when I was supercharged. But I wouldn't go buy a china turbo off ebay and stick it on my car.
Larger or more complex products have more flaws, quality and fitment issues coming from China.
Larger or more complex products have more flaws, quality and fitment issues coming from China.
#7
I would buy the same quality part for a lower price if it was made in china. if I wanted a **** part I could probably find a **** American made one as well. I don't do the buy American bullshit. this is a global economy and if we want to prove we are the best in the world we need to compete.
#8
Senior Member
iTrader: (6)
Join Date: 08-15-07
Location: texas
Posts: 1,669
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I voted no as well. If you get a chinese part your going to save some money yes, but your eventually going to have to replace it again and then wheres the savings? Please keep things made in the US!
#9
Senior Member
iTrader: (6)
Join Date: 08-15-07
Location: texas
Posts: 1,669
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Also as a business strategy, making parts made in china would be a bad idea because then your product would be the same quality as 50% of the junk on ebay, but youd have to sell a little more than what ebay sells for and where the profit in that? Anyone could just buy parts on ebay instead.
#12
It really depends what it is. ZZP's dual pass is made in China. It served me well for 2 years when I was supercharged. But I wouldn't go buy a china turbo off ebay and stick it on my car.
Larger or more complex products have more flaws, quality and fitment issues coming from China.
Larger or more complex products have more flaws, quality and fitment issues coming from China.
All of the stage 1 axles are. The driveshaft shop stuff is not.
#13
Senior Member
As it's already been said, its a global economy. I'll buy from whoever has the best price/quality. The US most certainly is not the end all in high quality. I've had many made in the USA pieces of poo and just as many cheap Chinese quality pieces. Just gotta shop around.
#15
As it's already been said, its a global economy. I'll buy from whoever has the best price/quality. The US most certainly is not the end all in high quality. I've had many made in the USA pieces of poo and just as many cheap Chinese quality pieces. Just gotta shop around.
#17
Senior Member
iTrader: (3)
What if you were shown something was made and designed in the USA and then bought it 6 months later from them and it was a Chinese part? Quality isn't as good, lets say 7.5 out of 10 compared to a 10 out of 10 for the USA part. Oh and it's the same price as before and you weren't told about this change of manufacturing origin.
if you are a vendor buying from a wholesaler or factory you should be notified.
if you joe schmoe buying something well tough **** i guess
#18
Senior Member
What if you were shown something was made and designed in the USA and then bought it 6 months later from them and it was a Chinese part? Quality isn't as good, lets say 7.5 out of 10 compared to a 10 out of 10 for the USA part. Oh and it's the same price as before and you weren't told about this change of manufacturing origin.
#19
Senior Member
iTrader: (1)
Depends on the item, if its an item that see's high stress all the time, generally I look to avoid made in china parts only because of the low quality materials and castings that generally come out of that country. I have had many things such as bolts, fittings, etc that were porous and brittle that were supposed to be high strength steel that literally broke apart in my hands. I had a made in china air compressor almost explode in my face one time when the brass fittings on the regular cracked off when attaching an air hose.
However as far as things like headers go, even things like intercoolers (cxracing) and other things that dont require as stringent material standards, ive bought plenty of those strictly because of the savings. Especially in the honda community. Custom headers can wind up costing between 800-1500 dollars in some cases, yet companys like private label mfg https://www.privatelabelmfg.com/ reproduce these headers at over half the cost with either the same quality or even BETTER some times with more parts included inthe package because of how low cost it is.
However as far as things like headers go, even things like intercoolers (cxracing) and other things that dont require as stringent material standards, ive bought plenty of those strictly because of the savings. Especially in the honda community. Custom headers can wind up costing between 800-1500 dollars in some cases, yet companys like private label mfg https://www.privatelabelmfg.com/ reproduce these headers at over half the cost with either the same quality or even BETTER some times with more parts included inthe package because of how low cost it is.
#20
Senior Member
iTrader: (1)
Perfectly legal wording, "designed in the usa, manufactured in china". Or even if you just used "designed in the USA" and left out the china part entirely. Question is does it meet the country's compliance standards for that product. Such as ROHS for electronics, as well as other standards.
#21
Senior Member
Perfectly legal wording, "designed in the usa, manufactured in china". Or even if you just used "designed in the USA" and left out the china part entirely. Question is does it meet the country's compliance standards for that product. Such as ROHS for electronics, as well as other standards.
#22
Senior Member
iTrader: (1)
And that would be fine as long as that is stated in the fine print of the advertising, however if you are showing me a USA made product at a certain quality level then you sell me something made else where at much lower quality with no indication of this, its called bait and switch.
#23
it doesnt this is just xenophobic bs. especially now that we are playing the what if game. its up to the seller to inform the buyer. if they switch suppliers and you dont let people know before you sell it to them its your fault.
#25
New Member
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: 09-05-09
Location: detroit
Posts: 148
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I know you've been around the forum forever you should've realized by now that 90% of owners are teenage/young 20s kids that only care about going the fastest for cheapest..most don't consider itll cost more down the road